Yumna Siddiqi
Professor Siddiqi is a wonderful professor who is deeply knowledgeable on the literature of forced migration, displacement and English as a language. However, she is also the most inconsistent grader I have had at Middlebury. The essay exams were in class, "open note" and graded harder than I've had any in-class essay graded. She grades for spelling and sentence structure as well as the development and themes throughout. These essays will make up a large portion of your grade and while you are allowed revisions, she will hand back the papers extremely late and give very little time to transcribe your entire essay onto a google doc and make revisions. All that said, you will read prolific Palestinian writing (Said, Barghouti and so-on) that will stick with you long after the class. I highly recommend the content of this course but the actual teaching at times is quite difficult.
Professor Siddiqi is a wonderful professor who is deeply knowledgeable on the literature of forced migration, displacement and English as a language. However, she is also the most inconsistent grader I have had at Middlebury. The essay exams were in class, "open note" and graded harder than I've had any in-class essay graded. She gra …Read more
I thoroughly enjoyed the content and readings in this course, but Prof. Siddiqi's teaching style and poor organization made the class completely unenjoyable. Her lectures were never clear and usually just recapped a theoretical reading we had done instead of building off of the text, and she would often go off on long tangents or forget what she was talking about. She would often change the syllabus and assigned readings more than halfway through the week before the next class (we met once a week for three hours) without warning. She also wanted students to lead discussions every week with a handout, but gave so little instruction or guidelines that these discussions were ineffective at starting a good dialogue between students to aid understanding of the course themes. I still got a lot out of it because the actual content was interesting, but I do not want to take another class with Prof. Siddiqi, as her teaching was unenjoyable.
I thoroughly enjoyed the content and readings in this course, but Prof. Siddiqi's teaching style and poor organization made the class completely unenjoyable. Her lectures were never clear and usually just recapped a theoretical reading we had done instead of building off of the text, and she would often go off on long tangents or for …Read more
Professor Siddiqi, was so lovely. Her class could be long and boring at many times, but she is really such a good person. I found the readings to be engaging but the writing was boring. It's a good J-term class if you want minimal homework, be prepared to sit through 3 painful hours of class per day though.